When I heard that a new version of Fame was coming to theaters, I was happy. The original was great and the topic still relevant (witness High School Musical, Glee, the films Camp and Center Stage).
So we went to see it last weekend. It was entertaining, but not brilliant. If you never saw the original, I'm sure the average person would like it. So too if you didn't compare it to the original. I approached it with an open mind.
There are lots of positive things to say. Naturi Naughton's take on "Out Here On My Own" was stunning. I even enjoyed the new take on the classic title track, which accompanied the closing credits.
The casting was well done, particularly the students. Charles Dutton was terrific as the drama teacher; I liked the warmth that Megan Mullally brought to her role, and Bibi Neuwirth is great in whatever she does. I would have liked more screen time for Debbie Allen, but so be it.
In anticipation of seeing this film, I watched the original a couple of weeks ago, the first time in many years. I had forgotten how potent it was. My teenage "stepdaughter" and I viewed it together and we both squirmed at various points.
This new version loses a lot of depth given to the original characters. We didn't see the struggles of Doris trying to become the person she aspires to, not what her mother envisions for her...Coco being pushed to the limits of her premature worldliness...Ralph's struggle to balance education and family responsibilities...Montgomery's forced adulthood as a gay man finding himself, without the benefit of involved parents. We see some of this in the 2009 version, but we're not allowed to be nearly as intimate with the new characters.
Using the same structure of the original was smart, but there were a couple of scenes recreated from the original. These, I could have done without. Particularly the "girl trying to find her identity meets sullen boy on the stairs outside the noisy lunchroom" scene. We knew exactly what was going to happen when Denise walked into the actor's trailer. But the scene was limp when compared to Coco's "screen test" with the nefarious Francois.
One other gripe and I will leave this alone. The original Fame wasn't afraid to deal with gay issues in the form of Montgomery. Remember, this was 1980, a time when gay characters weren't that plentiful. This new incarnation stays away from it completely. I'm sorry, but this is 2009. You know that PA is loaded with gay boys prancing down the halls. One of the lead characters should have been gay.
In closing, I will say again...it was entertaining. I didn't hate it. I just wish this had been more of a "reimagining" of Fame, rather than a remake. And I wish that the original creative team had done this film. It would have been really interesting to see their take on the material, nearly 30 years later.